The New York Times Wirecutter chose Benjamin Moore Regal Select as the top interior paint after 30 hours of researching 55 different paints. They also feature stains, primers, and specialty paints. There were differing opinions on issues like customer service, suggesting it varies by location. Paint Colour Review: A Blue-Green Blend - Sherwin Williams Silver Strand. Lets recap the key takeaways of this comparison before you decide: With paint, you typically get what you pay for. Behr paint is a lot cheaper than Sherwin Williams. You also automatically get a PaintPerks account that saves you money on purchases. At Painters Inc., we use the best tools and the best paint because we're committed to quality finishes and pleasing our customers. Both Matt Kunz, president of Five Star Painting, and Michael Camper of M&M Precision Painting said Sherwin-Williams has superior color-matching software and mixer. In this comparison of Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams, I share my findings. Yes, but experts said Sherwin-Williams is a bit better. Cashmere from Sherwin-Williams is an interior paint that's available in five finishes, from flat to a higher-gloss Medium Lustre. Both brands are accessible. Regal Select is more forgiving, he said, so you don't have to worry as much about imperfections in the wall if you're a DIYer. This week we put the Sherwin Williams Emerald Urethane Vs Benjamin Moore Advance where we look at the look, feel, chemical, mar, and adhesion differences.Tec. Great review, very thorough. Price. *At the time of publishing . "What we find is like certain crews will get very used to using one of the types of paints, and they'll lean towards it because they know just without even thinking about it," said Kunz. HU-835795514. Types of Benjamin Moore Paint: A Guide to Help You Choose. Yes, experts said Sherwin-Williams has the edge. Use the Sherwin-Williams store locator to find the nearest store. In fact, we rank Behr close to our vary favorite paint brands, like Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams. My home I live in builders painted with SW flat finish promax 200, lowest grade. Deck stains also come in a variety of types: Transparent, Semi-Transparent, and Semi-Solids that will determine the opacity of the stain when applied to the wood Behr was also commended for its coverage and smooth application and also stood out for its mildew resistance. The top end Behr applies like honey or yogurt. With Sherwin-Williams, "the more coats you apply, the shinier it gets," he said. ). Your experience will vary based on who you talk to, but it was clear from the handful of discussions I had that Sherwin-Williams puts more emphasis on customer service. On their website, Sherwin Williams has a rating of 2.8 stars out of 5 while Benjamin Moore has a rating of 3.5 stars. Sherwin-Williams Cashmere vs. Emerald: Which Paint Line Is Better? 2023 Prudent Reviews LLC. The Ultra line is very similar in nature to Benjamin Moore's Aura and is great for homes with children. Join our free newsletter and get the latest reviews, deals, giveaways, and exclusive content. Many pro painters will sacrifice quality for cost. Behr vs. Sherwin-Williams: Comparison Chart, What Experts at Home Depot and Sherwin-Williams Stores Say. Finally, testers were able to remove stains without damaging the finish. Sherwin-Williams Paint Lines This section will cover each brand's most popular paints, starting with Benjamin Moore. Additives give the paint different qualities, such as fade resistance or thick consistency. Duration will stop streaking on the walls, but is not good with extreme moisture caused by consistent hot showers without ventilation., Infinity Painting, a contractor in Connecticut, mentioned, Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams both have excellent products. Behr offers the following tools to help you find the perfect color: Popular Color Search/Color Selection Tool: Explore Behrs most popular collections or use the color wheel to quickly find your desired color. Sales are another factor to keep in mind. Behr Premium Plus Interior Paint: An affordable, low-VOC paint. It is a major reason why many pros will prefer SW over BM. Sherwin-Williams came in second as another popular brand of choice for homeowners and home designers. Satin vs. Semi-Gloss Polyurethane: Whats the Difference? One tip we found browsing a Reddit page for Sherwin-Williams employees was to avoid visiting a paint store when they first open for the day. The expert at National Lumber Home Finishes, an authorized Benjamin Moore dealer in Massachusetts, told me, Benjamin Moore is one of the best paints on the market. Pictured above in Addisons Wonderlands Brittany Hayes's entryway, she used this color in such a unique way and I love it paired with the soft blue hue on the door. Benjamin Moore vs. Sherwin-Williams: Comparison Chart. The chart below shows the VOC levels of Behr and Sherwin-Williams most popular paint lines. Youll learn how they compare in terms of: Plus, I reveal what experienced paint professionals say about Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams. You can order it online, but you must pick it up at a Sherwin-Williams store. Sherwin-Williams Duration vs. Emerald: Which Paint Is Better? "Arborcoat doesn't do that. Sample jars: If you're stuck between a few colors, you can buy small quantities of paint from both companies and test them out. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), solvents may cause adverse health effects, such as respiratory irritation, headaches, or nausea. Bottom line you really cant go wrong with either. Note: If a paint line does not offer an interior or exterior version, you will see N/A in the column. That's when pros pick up supplies, and the workers won't have time to answer detailed questions. When I asked the expert at National Lumber Home Finishes if Benjamin Moore is really worth twice as much as Behr in some cases, he claimed that Benjamin Moore is one of the best paints you can buy. Behr: Behr is a popular paint brand that is available at most home improvement stores. Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200 vs. ProMar 400: Whats the Difference? Furthermore, Sherwin-Williams collaborates with other businesses in the home decor vertical, such as Pottery Barn and West Elm, and offers collections inspired by these partnerships. You should also stay out of freshly painted rooms for a few days. In contrast, Benjamin Moore aims to create the best-performing paint and prices it accordingly. Behr has low-cost options in their water-based paints, whereas Benjamin Moore has a consistently higher price. But to gain an in-depth understanding, lets look at the structure of paint. Powers paint rating which rated the Sherwin Williams paint products significantly better overall than the Behr brand. Reply with quote. Good Housekeeping called out both brands in its Top Interior Paint Color list. We recommend that all customers start their search by first identifying their desired color, and then selecting the product, sheen, size, quantity, and more. I truly believe these folks are just budget minded and don't know the benefits of better paint. In fact, it was strikingly similar to Aura in terms of quality. It doesn't show up under green at all! The interior paint has antimicrobial properties. Almost everyone we spoke with also suggested using higher-quality, more expensive paint. Upgrading your home's exterior? The reviewers also love the convenience of being able to buy in-store or online through Home Depot. You can see from the picture above how much creamier it looks compared to Frost. Join our free newsletter and get the latest reviews, deals, giveaways, and exclusive content. It offers a paint and primer combination, is easy to apply, and contains low VOCs. Benjamin Moore and Sherwin-Williams both offer a range of interior and exterior paints in different finishes and formulas. Shop and explore your favorite paint brands - we match more than 250,000 colors from Pantone, RAL and all major paint brands, including Benjamin Moore, Sherwin-Williams and more. Email us at reviews@insider.com. Behr vs. Benjamin Moore: Which Paint Is Better? Benjamin Moore is sold at a wide variety of paint and home improvement stores and offers their customers three common kinds of paint, semi-gloss, flat, and eggshell. It has excellent coverage, scrubbability, and durability. Both products have excellent durability, adhesiveness, coverage, and many other attributes. When I spoke to each painter, I asked the same two questions: New Haven Painters, a company based in Connecticut, told me, There is not an overall consensus on which paint brand is better. Business Insider listed the Best Interior Paints and chose HGTV by Sherwin-Williams Infinity as the Best Paint for a Makeover. Behr Dynasty Interior Paint: This is Behrs newest, most premium, and expensive paint. In the example above, you can see that Sherwin Williams' version of Egecombe Gray is a warmer color than the actual color when both samples are wet (ie they're not actually wet YET, they're definitely dry). It features a button you can click whenever you see something online that inspires you. It varies by line. You can buy ben interior in flat, eggshell, and semi-gloss. People often wonder, "What Benjamin Moore color is closest to Accessible Beige?" There are no real exact matches between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams paint colors, both because formulas are different and because the actual paint products are different (and differing paint products can make even the same formula look different! You do have to register with your email to use it. The technology also produces consistent color with fewer chemicals. Kitchen & CookingHome MaintenanceCleaningHome EssentialsBrowse All CategoriesBrowse All Brands, About UsHow We Test ProductsContact UsJobsTerms & ConditionsPrivacy Policy. 2023 Prudent Reviews LLC. Sherwin-Williams' 8-by-8-inch peel and stick squares are each $3.95. Aura will prevent mildew and cracking from extreme moisture. But prices range significantly by line. You have a choice of finishes for each, such as flat, satin, semi-gloss, or high-gloss, with access to all Behr colors for each option. It praised its brush-stroke-free coverage, choice of sheens, and custom hue options. But there are few instances where they might prefer one over the other. In general, both brands are high-end as far as quality and cost. Color chips: After picking a color family or specific hue, you'll want to start comparing different shades to each other. Benjamin Moore Ultra Flat Waterborne Ceiling paint was the top pick for ceiling paint because it resists gravitational drip, contains zero VOCs, and leaves a near flawless finish that hides imperfections well. Theres 1 extremely important point I didnt notice in your review: Sherwin Williams offers deep discounts on their paints. Though they're pricier, self-leveling paints like Benjamin Moore Aura or Sherwin-Williams Emerald Urethane (for trim) may be a little more forgiving of wall flaws and brushstrokes. In fact, the EPA banned using the solvent methylene chloride in consumer paint brands. Swiss Coffee would look great on walls, cabinetry and trim. Note: If a paint line does not offer a specific finish, youll see N/A (not applicable) in that column. Testers remarked that it offered complete coverage over black and white surfaces with ease. Decks stain brands differ though drastically in the ingredients, solids, etc. How does it feel when rolling or brushing and how is the coverage? Camper said regardless of a brand's claim that it only needs one coat, you should do a second and prime your walls first. Good Housekeepings 5-star review of Benjamin Moore Regal Select reveals only upsides, including superior coverage, above-average stain removal, high wear resistance, excellent finish, and low VOCs. Thinner paint with lower volume solids is better for using a spray, but higher volume solids indicate better quality paint in most cases.